Nick Pelios
Freediver, Creator
Share this on
Nick Pelios
Freediver, Creator
The journey from a casual freediver to a more serious one comes with many milestones. The first time you hit 20 meters, your first breath-hold beyond two minutes, or perhaps your first successful spearfishing trip. Along the way, it’s natural to start asking questions about your equipment. Chief among these: Should I switch to carbon fins?
It’s a question that’s loaded with implications. Carbon fins aren’t just a piece of gear—they’re an investment. The leap from basic plastic fins to carbon fiber models is significant in terms of both performance and cost. But that doesn’t mean it’s a leap you shouldn’t take. It just means timing is everything.
If you’re a beginner, plastic fins are your best friend. Affordable, durable, and forgiving, they’re like the trusty old car you learned to drive on—not flashy, but reliable.
Plastic fins have a predictable flex pattern, which means they’re less responsive but easier to control. This makes them ideal for learning basic techniques without overwhelming your muscles. They can handle rough treatment—rocky entries, accidental scrapes, and less-than-perfect storage practices—without falling apart.
In short, plastic fins are perfect when you’re still figuring out what kind of freediver you are. Deep diver? Recreational explorer? Spearfisher? They let you experiment without pressure. But as you get deeper—both literally and figuratively—those plastic fins start to feel like a bottleneck.
So, how do you know it’s time to upgrade? The transition isn’t based on how long you’ve been freediving but rather on a few key indicators:
You’ve Hit a Performance Plateau: If you’re consistently freediving in the 20-30 meter range and feel like your legs are screaming for mercy every time you ascend, your fins might be holding you back. Carbon fins require far less effort for the same propulsion compared to plastic. The result? Less oxygen consumption and more efficiency—two things every freediver craves.
Your Technique Is Solid: Switching to carbon fins prematurely can be counterproductive. Carbon fins are incredibly responsive, meaning they’ll amplify both good and bad technique. If your kick is messy or uneven, carbon fins will punish you. If you’ve spent time honing your kick cycle, body position, and overall form, you’ll feel the immediate benefit of carbon fins. They’ll work with you rather than against you, offering a sense of flow and ease that plastic fins just can’t deliver.
You’re Diving Deeper and Longer: The deeper you go, the more every small inefficiency is magnified. Plastic fins, though dependable, become noticeably less effective at greater depths. The increased water pressure reduces their flex, making them feel like you’re kicking with a plank of wood. Carbon fins, on the other hand, retain their responsiveness even at depth. They give you that extra boost when you need it most—during your ascent, when every kick counts.
You’re Ready for an Investment: Let’s be real, carbon fins aren’t cheap. A good pair can cost several hundred euros. It’s an investment not just in equipment but also in your own growth as a freediver. Think of it as the difference between buying a bicycle to get around town and investing in a high-performance road bike for long-distance rides. Both will get you from point A to point B, but one is clearly built for bigger things.
When you do make the switch, the difference is night and day. It’s not just about going deeper or conserving energy—it’s about how the whole experience transforms.
Carbon fins offer:
Efficiency: Every kick translates into more distance with less effort.
Comfort: You’ll experience less fatigue, which means longer, more enjoyable sessions.
Control: Carbon fins are incredibly responsive, allowing for precise movements and faster adjustments.
Durability (with care): While they require more attention than plastic, quality carbon fins can last years if treated well.
They’re Fragile: Yes, carbon fins require more care than plastic, but they’re not as fragile as people think. High-quality carbon fins, like those produced by Alchemy, are built to withstand regular use in the water. Avoid rocky entries and store them properly, and they’ll last a long time.
They’re Only for Pros: It’s easy to fall into the mindset that carbon fins are only for elite freedivers. Not true. While professionals certainly benefit from them, intermediate freedivers can also see massive improvements. The key is understanding your own needs and goals.
They’ll Instantly Make You a Better Diver: Switching to carbon fins won’t magically add 10 meters to your dive. What they will do is give you the tools to go further, provided you’ve put in the work.
If you’ve decided it’s time to upgrade, the next step is figuring out which carbon fins are right for you. This is where things can get a bit overwhelming. There are different stiffness levels, blade lengths, and footpocket compatibility to consider.
Here are a few tips to help you narrow it down:
Match the Blade Stiffness to Your Strength and Style: If you’re a smaller diver or prefer a slow, relaxed style, go for softer blades. Stronger divers or those aiming for maximum speed may prefer medium or even stiff blades.
Consider the Angle: Blade angle affects how comfortable the fins feel during surface swimming and descents. A 23-degree angle (like the Alchemy V3 Pro) offers a balance of power and comfort, while a 30-degree angle (Alchemy V330 Pro) is easier on the legs, especially on longer dives.
Think About Footpockets: Footpockets can drastically change the performance and comfort of your fins. For example, C4 250 footpockets are incredibly light with no tendons, offering top performance, while Mares X-Wing footpockets provide a more structured feel.
Switching to carbon fins is a milestone in your freediving journey, but it’s not a race. There’s no shame in sticking with plastic fins until you’re truly ready. Take your time to refine your technique, build your confidence, and decide what kind of freediver you want to be. When the time comes to make the leap, you’ll know. And when you do, you’ll wonder how you ever lived without them.